|| No immunity for prosecutor accused of misconduct|
immunity for prosecutor accused of misconduct
Hollywood couldn’t come up with a better script than this. A gang member
was convicted in 1986 of double murder by two prosecutors who are now accused of
coercing witnesses into giving false testimony against him; and he was sentenced
to death by a judge who had taken a bribe from his co-defendant.
One of those two prosecutors will have to answer for his alleged actions
after the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last week that
he did not have immunity.
According to a Monday article at Courthouse News, a divided three-judge
panel ruled that former Illinois assistant state attorney Lawrence Wharrie could
be sued civilly by Nathson Fields, the man who was convicted in 1986 for the
murders. Prosecutors generally have absolute immunity from civil suits for their
actions during the course of a criminal prosecution, and the panel held that
Wharrie’s co-counsel, former assistant state attorney David Kelley, was
immune. Fields had spent 17 years in prison before he was acquitted during a
retrial in 2009. (Thomas Maloney, the judge who presided over Fields' first
trial, was convicted of taking bribes and sentenced to more than 15 years in
prison, according to the Chicago Tribune. He died in 2008.)
"Wharrie is asking us to bless a breathtaking injustice," 7th
Circuit Judge Richard Posner wrote for the majority (PDF) . According to Posner,
Wharrie could be sued because he was accused of acting outside of the boundaries
of his job by performing an investigative role prior to the start of the
prosecution against Fields. Kelley, on the other hand, was protected because his
alleged actions took place while preparing for trial—when a prosecutor
unquestionably has immunity.
Circuit Court Judge Diane Sykes dissented, arguing that the case law in the
7th Circuit was unclear as to the scope of prosecutorial immunity. Sykes pointed
out that a recent 7th Circuit decision held that prosecutors might have
qualified immunity even when coercing testimony. She argued that the law needed
to be clarified.
We try to keep price lists up to date. Price list of our pharmacies are updated daily - go to pharmacy online : Announcements of new drugs. Shares. Best price.
| Related Links|
| Article Rating|